BofA: DRAM Still Holding Firm, NAND Quietly Weakening as Memory Market Diverges

AI data centerDRAMNANDMemory ChipsHBMsemiconductorsBofASamsung
5 hours agoSource: blockweeks.com
BofA: DRAM Still Holding Firm, NAND Quietly Weakening as Memory Market Diverges

Author: Xu Chao, Wallstreetcn

The memory chip market is shifting from a "broad rally" to "divergence." Bank of America believes that the price-increase logic for DRAM has not yet been broken, while the NAND spot market has clearly loosened and will become the first product category in this memory upcycle that needs to be repriced.

A Bank of America report dated November 13 shows that NAND spot prices have fallen significantly, with 512Gb wafers down more than 10% and 1Tb down nearly mid-single digits, while 16Gb DDR5 spot prices were flat. Since mid-to-late October, NAND spot prices have cumulatively corrected by about 20%.

Bank of America: DRAM remains firm, NAND has quietly weakened, memory is diverging

Based on this, Bank of America maintains a cautious assumption for NAND average selling prices in the first quarter of 2027: IT NAND prices down 5% to 10% quarter-on-quarter, enterprise applications basically flat or slightly up, and an overall low-single-digit decline. This judgment forms a clear divergence from the market's view, which still expects NAND selling prices to rise by more than 10%. At the same time, Bank of America still assumes DRAM price increases will continue into the fourth quarter of 2026 (up 8% quarter-on-quarter) and the first quarter of 2027 (up 5%).

Bank of America said that after conversations with investors this week, sentiment on memory stocks has improved compared with last week, and companies with higher DRAM weighting are seen as having limited downside. Most DRAM names currently trade at only 3 to 5 times price-to-earnings for 2026 to 2027 earnings, significantly below AI semiconductor peers.

Three signals of weakening NAND spot prices

Bank of America attributes NAND concerns to three points: spot prices have corrected by about 20% since mid-to-late October; orders from PC and smartphone OEMs and even Chinese hyperscale cloud providers have weakened; and contract price negotiations for the first quarter of 2027 may be delayed, with no rush orders appearing in the market.

The divergence in spot data is quite intuitive. According to DRAMeXchange, 512Gb wafer spot prices are quoted at $14.3, down 12% week-on-week and down 32% quarter-on-quarter, but still up 121% year-on-year; 1Tb is quoted at $24.9, down 4% week-on-week, down 19% quarter-on-quarter, and up 194% year-on-year. By comparison, 16Gb DDR5 is quoted at $60.2, flat week-on-week and up 150% year-on-year.

The original manufacturers' stance still emphasizes strong enterprise SSD demand, which can offset weakness in IT NAND to some extent.But Bank of America cautions that older production lines account for 20% to 30% of total global wafer capacity and are not suitable for producing high-end NAND and eSSD, so they still need to be continuously used for IT NAND, which constitutes structural pressure on prices. Per-bit prices for high-capacity NAND (above 2Tb) and eSSD (above 30TB) have been slightly lowered, but Bank of America views this more as proactive promotion by manufacturers to push the new-generation QLC—NAND prices for most eSSD are still trending slightly upward.

Point of divergence: contract prices remain high, but negotiations may be delayed

NAND contract prices and spot prices are currently diverging.

According to TrendForce, the October contract price for 1Tb TLC wafers was basically flat quarter-on-quarter, extending the sideways pattern from the second to third quarters; the 512Gb contract price is about $27, close to a historical high and roughly ten times the low of $2.5 in February 2025.

Bank of America: DRAM remains firm, NAND has quietly weakened, memory is diverging

Bank of America's concern lies in timing: if downstream buyers delay placing urgent orders, contract price negotiations for the first quarter of 2027 may be pushed back, and manufacturers' bargaining power in the new round of price talks will be weakened. This judgment directly corresponds to its expectation gap with the market—sell-side generally assumes NAND selling prices will still rise by about 10%, while Bank of America gives a low-single-digit decline.

Bank of America: DRAM remains firm, NAND has quietly weakened, memory is diverging

The DRAM side presents a different picture. According to TrendForce, the October contract price for 16Gb DDR5 rose another 5% quarter-on-quarter, with a year-on-year increase of more than 500%; October contract prices for 64GB server-side DDR5 and DDR4 modules rose about 15% quarter-on-quarter, with module prices having exceeded $1,000, reaching $1,600 and $1,500 respectively. On this basis, Bank of America maintains its assumption that DRAM will rise 8% quarter-on-quarter in the fourth quarter of 2026 and 5% in the first quarter of 2027.

Samsung: optimistic on HBM, but not aggressive

Bank of America held an investor exchange meeting with Samsung Electronics on November 12, and the three key takeaways were: demand for AI data center chips in the United States is strong, and despite concerns, no order cuts have been seen; HBM market position has improved markedly from weakness a year ago; and long-term agreement (LTA) prices for the DRAM business are rising strongly, with high selling prices and high gross margins sustainable over a long cycle.

But management's remarks were not aggressive, which is also one of the focuses for investors. Samsung set an HBM share target of about 30% to 40%, rather than above 50%; even by the end of 2027, LPDDR5 profitability will still be better than HBM, so HBM capacity expansion is unlikely to be too aggressive, in order to avoid eroding traditional DRAM market share. On the technology roadmap, HBM4e will share the same 1c node and 4nm logic chip with HBM4. Bank of America also mentioned that the magnitude of 2027 contract price increases is unlikely to reach TrendForce's expected level, because prices already rose earlier in 2026.

It is worth noting that Samsung's guidance for IT NAND is not as optimistic as for eSSD, which is consistent with Bank of America's price judgment.

Sentiment recovers, valuation remains the main support

Memory stocks rebounded this week, with year-to-date gains generally above 100%, and SanDisk and Kioxia posting year-to-date returns of more than 250%. Bank of America said investors it spoke with this week generally mentioned limited downside, citing resilient AIDC chip orders after the U.S. midterm elections, DRAM selling prices still rising (in contrast to NAND), and low valuation multiples.

The valuation table shows SK Hynix at 3.6 times 2026 price-to-earnings, Samsung at 4.7 times, Micron at 10.7 times, and Nanya at 5.1 times; among the NAND camp, Sandisk is at 4.3 times 2027 price-to-earnings, Western Digital at 13.2 times, SIMO at 16.4 times, and Phison at 7.7 times. Bank of America believes that compared with AI semiconductor peers, the memory sector's pricing still appears moderate.

Bank of America concludes that DRAM supply-demand and price trends remain supported by AI data centers and HBM crowding out capacity, while NAND pricing power is shifting toward buyers. The valuation gap and earnings elasticity of the two will depend on whether contract price negotiations for the first quarter of 2027 can land as scheduled.