S&P Keeps Tether's USDT at Lowest Stability Score as Risky Asset Exposure Climbs to 28%

USDT
BTC
TetherUSDT
5 hours agoSource: crypto.news
S&P Keeps Tether's USDT at Lowest Stability Score as Risky Asset Exposure Climbs to 28%

S&P Global Ratings has maintained its stablecoin stability assessment of Tether’s USDT at the lowest level on its five-point scale, warning that growing exposure to higher-risk assets could leave the world’s largest stablecoin undercollateralized during a market downturn.

Summary

  • S&P maintained USDT’s weakest stability score as higher-risk asset exposure hit 28%.
  • Tether’s gold holdings reached $19B while public equity investments rose to $4.2B.
  • Tether reported $191.45B in assets against $183.50B in liabilities in September.
  • S&P flagged transparency concerns despite Tether completing its first KPMG audit.
  • Tether rejected S&P’s stability assessment and criticized its evaluation framework.

In its Nov. 18 assessment, S&P assigned USDT a score of 5 (weak), unchanged from November 2025, after finding that assets it considers higher risk were equivalent to 28% of circulating USDT as of Sept. 30, compared with 24% a year earlier.

The assessment measures a stablecoin’s ability to maintain its dollar peg and does not constitute a formal credit rating.

However, Tether rejected the findings, arguing that shortcomings in S&P’s methodology were responsible for the unfavorable assessment.

“The problem is S&P’s framework, not our reserves,” the company told Cointelegraph, referring to the 2008 financial crisis and its portrayal in the film The Big Short when criticizing the agency.

Tether’s exposure to gold and equities grows

S&P identified changes in Tether’s reserve composition over the past year, particularly its growing investments in gold and publicly traded stocks, despite a reduction in its Bitcoin exposure.

Gold holdings rose from $12.9 billion in September 2025 to approximately $19 billion a year later, while Bitcoin holdings declined from $9.9 billion to $8.4 billion. Tether introduced $4.2 billion in public equity investments during the same period.

The agency’s higher-risk asset category includes corporate bonds, secured loans and other investments exposed to fluctuations in market prices, interest rates and the creditworthiness of borrowers.

“A significant drop in the value of these assets could lead to USDT being undercollateralized,” S&P warned.

Nevertheless, Tether’s reserves continued to exceed its outstanding obligations at the end of September. Its latest financial figures, attested by BDO Italia, showed $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in total liabilities, giving the issuer a collateralization ratio of 104.3%.

Source: S&P
Source: S&P

As crypto.news previously reported, Tether’s excess reserve buffer nearly doubled from $4.11 billion at the end of June to $7.95 billion at the end of September, alongside quarterly net operating profit of $1.5 billion.

The company’s direct and indirect exposure to U.S. Treasury bills stood at $132.4 billion, with Treasury bills and reverse repurchase agreements generating most of its operating income.

However, S&P noted that the value of higher-risk assets substantially exceeded the available reserve surplus.

S&P questions Tether’s financial disclosures despite KPMG audit

Reserve transparency remains another point of disagreement between the stablecoin issuer and the ratings agency.

In August, Tether announced the completion of its first full independent audit, with KPMG U.S. issuing an unqualified opinion on its financial statements for the year ended Dec. 31, 2025.

The audit examined financial transactions, asset valuations, ownership records and counterparty information. Tether said KPMG physically inspected and counted every gold bar held by the company.

Despite the audit’s completion, S&P noted that the financial statements, accompanying notes and auditor’s report remained unavailable to the public, limiting its ability to examine the underlying information.

Tether’s quarterly reserve reports do not identify its custodians, banking partners or counterparties. S&P found that disclosures concerning the composition and credit quality of secured loans and corporate bonds remained insufficient.

The company’s CEO, Paolo Ardoino, had previously criticized S&P’s assessment after the agency lowered USDT’s stability score from 4 to 5 in November 2025.

El Salvador’s regulatory framework draws scrutiny

S&P questioned the legal protections surrounding USDT’s reserves following Tether’s relocation from the British Virgin Islands to El Salvador in 2025.

The company operates under the supervision of El Salvador’s National Commission of Digital Assets, which requires stablecoin issuers to maintain at least one dollar in reserve assets for every dollar of stablecoins issued.

At least 70% of those reserves must be invested in assets that can be liquidated within 30 days.

However, S&P considers the framework less stringent than its European and U.S. counterparts because it permits exposure to assets such as Bitcoin, gold and loans without requiring reserve segregation.

The agency found insufficient public information to determine how USDT’s reserves would be protected against issuer insolvency or financial difficulties arising from Tether’s other business ventures, which include artificial intelligence and Bitcoin mining.

Tether maintains that its non-stablecoin operations are managed separately from USDT’s reserves.

USDT maintains price stability despite redemption limitations

Although S&P retained its weakest assessment, the agency acknowledged USDT’s history of maintaining its dollar peg, particularly over the past 12 months.

Direct redemptions remain limited to verified customers holding at least $100,000 in Tether tokens. The issuer’s official fee schedule specifies a $150 verification charge and a redemption fee of $1,000 or 0.1%, whichever is higher.

S&P noted that strong liquidity across centralized and decentralized exchanges partially offsets these restrictions, although direct redemption payments remain constrained by conventional banking hours.

As of Oct. 25, Tron accounted for 50.7% of circulating USDT, followed by Ethereum at 46.8% and Solana at 1.6%, with the three networks collectively hosting 99.1% of the stablecoin’s circulating supply.